Warning: Use of undefined constant referer - assumed 'referer' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /usr/home/essaywo/public_html/essays on line 102

Warning: Use of undefined constant host - assumed 'host' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /usr/home/essaywo/public_html/essays on line 105

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /usr/home/essaywo/public_html/essays:102) in /usr/home/essaywo/public_html/essays on line 106

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /usr/home/essaywo/public_html/essays:102) in /usr/home/essaywo/public_html/essays on line 109
"Stop Seeking Certainty.." Minow's Response To Bork - College Essays

"Stop Seeking Certainty.." Minow's Response To Bork



Philosophy Of Law
In considering the views of Robert Bork and Martha Minow, I am
impressed more by Minow. I will compare their respective views and
arguments in an effort to show why I prefer the arguments of Minow to those
of Bork. First though it is necessary to have a brief overview of Bork's
philosophy.

Bork is a firm believer in the originalist mode of Constitutional
interpretation. Many different scholars may have differing views as to the
meaning of the word originalism. Here, it is intended to define "an..
approach to constitutional adjudication that accords binding authority to
the text of the Constitution or the intentions of it's adopters" (Lyons, pp.
329). This ...

Want to read the rest of this paper?
Join Essayworld today to view this entire essay
and over 50,000 other term papers

text merely provides clues as to the intent of the above
mentioned groups. So peripheral documents, such as the Federalist papers,
are important clarifiers of the original intent. The second subdivision of
orginalism is called the textual orginialist view. This view argues that
the actual text of the Constitution is what is most important in terms of
understanding Constitutional intent. Bork began as an intention theorist,
then later changed and came to adopt the textual originalist view point.
Neither subdivision of the view of orginalism is very popular today, as is
evidenced by the fact that Bork was not confirmed by the Congress when he
was nominated for the Supreme Court. Bork argues that by reading the text,
and figuring out what the public understanding of the Constitution was at
the time of it's writing, we can discern what the Constitution actually
means. The problem here is obvious. It is very difficult to know what the
public understanding at the time of ...

Get instant access to over 50,000 essays.
Write better papers. Get better grades.


Already a member? Login

principle as it relates to constitutional
interpretation. According to Bork, a judge should make a decision based
only on an original intent understanding of a given law in a given case.
No personal pr eferences should come into play. Instead, legal principles
should be applied equally across all cases which those principles encompass.
It is Bork's assertion that his philosophy of original understanding can
supply neutrality in deriving, defining and applying any legal principle.
(Bork, pp. 53) So, on to the distinctions between deriving, defining and
applying. On the issue of derivation, Bork argues that via his
philosophical view of original intent, it is possible to derive ...

Succeed in your coursework without stepping into a library.
Get access to a growing library of notes, book reports,
and research papers in 2 minutes or less.


CITE THIS PAGE:

"Stop Seeking Certainty.." Minow's Response To Bork. (2004, November 15). Retrieved December 23, 2024, from http://www.essayworld.com/essays/Stop-Seeking-Certainty-Minows-Response-Bork/17520
""Stop Seeking Certainty.." Minow's Response To Bork." Essayworld.com. Essayworld.com, 15 Nov. 2004. Web. 23 Dec. 2024. <http://www.essayworld.com/essays/Stop-Seeking-Certainty-Minows-Response-Bork/17520>
""Stop Seeking Certainty.." Minow's Response To Bork." Essayworld.com. November 15, 2004. Accessed December 23, 2024. http://www.essayworld.com/essays/Stop-Seeking-Certainty-Minows-Response-Bork/17520.
""Stop Seeking Certainty.." Minow's Response To Bork." Essayworld.com. November 15, 2004. Accessed December 23, 2024. http://www.essayworld.com/essays/Stop-Seeking-Certainty-Minows-Response-Bork/17520.
JOIN NOW
Join today and get instant access to this and 50,000+ other essays


PAPER DETAILS
Added: 11/15/2004 05:30:00 AM
Category: Government
Type: Premium Paper
Words: 2211
Pages: 9

Save | Report

SHARE THIS PAPER

SAVED ESSAYS
Save and find your favorite essays easier

SIMILAR ESSAYS
» Money
» Grenada
» Nuclear Energy
» Romeo and Juliet Q&A
» What is the Greenhouse Effect?
» Henry Adams, Virgin And The Dy
» Hawks
» Heroic Qualities In The Hobbit
» History
» Lupus
Copyright | Cancel | Contact Us

Copyright © 2024 Essayworld. All rights reserved